Reducing Study Team Burden with Targeted Training
An approach to training that carefully targets site and individual weak areas, along with critical protocol procedures, could not only reduce deviations, but can play a key role in reducing overall burdens on research site personnel.
Booming administrative tasks, customized technology systems and redundant certification and training requirements are among the primary factors that clinical research staff say eats up time better spent with patients and adds excessive burden—often uncompensated—to study teams. Some of these developments have been laid at the feet of growing protocol complexity and trial sizes, which are likely problems that are here to stay. But others lie within sponsors’ capacity to change.
In August 2020, CenterWatch reported that sites were feeling overwhelmed by growing administrative responsibilities. CenterWatch pointed to a survey indicating that about 80% of sites found that administrative responsibilities—such as managing study documents and regulatory file preparation—had increased “significantly” or “somewhat” over the preceding two years. Increased diversity in individual sponsors’ requirements, increased site responsibilities and increased protocol complexity topped the list of items most burdensome to sites.
Any given line item on a research professional’s task list in a protocol could include multiple steps, such as meetings, patient visits, labs and procedures, Beth Harper, chief learning officer at Pro-ficiency, noted. For instance, a protocol might call for patients to have two options—one on-site and one virtual—for some visits. That is convenient for patients, but that means that a site has to develop two pathways, along with the requisite training for both site staff and for patients.
The number of hours a site is putting into preparing for a study is the amount of time they are not working on that study, Jenna Rouse, chief experience officer at Pro-ficiency, said. Sponsors need to consider whether they would ask their own teams to do the same.
“The time taken to deal with these burdens is time that cannot be patient-facing or study-facing,” Scott Ballenger agreed. “I think it also weighs on the relationship with the sponsor and CRO, as well as contributing to site staff burnout.”
This is not a new problem. In a 2016 white paper, WCG pointed to use of multiple systems as a major source of overwork for clinical study teams. In the decade-plus preceding the white paper, biopharma companies began using individual clinical trial, regulatory, drug safety and learning management systems from a variety of vendors. These, in turn were customized to be more client-centric, which made it difficult for vendors to integrate their own products even within a single sponsor, much less across multiple companies and studies.
Specialized technology can also pose a burden. Ballenger noted that many a study comes with a unique suite of software applications, each of those requiring a learning curve. While some may be intuitive to use, others are frustrating and time-consuming.
And not only are all these processes cumbersome and a drain on site professionals’ time, but they also up the possibility for errors or protocol deviations, which can add to the time and cost needed to complete a clinical trial. In its January/February 2022 Impact Report, Tufts Center for the Study of Drug Development (CSDD) reported that the number of protocol deviations and substantial amendments seen in clinical trials has increased in recent years.
“Deviations are a sign that something is not in accord with the protocol,” Rouse said. “If you train in a way that highlights areas where staff may not understand how their job is to be done in a specific trial, you can take action before deviations start costing sponsors money and research sites time for retraining.”
Targeted training holds answers
And training is one area in which sponsors can exercise a great deal of control over the time burdens they place on sites. Regulations require that sponsors provide appropriate training, so the safest position for pharma companies is to provide an immense amount of information on everything possible, Jeff Kingsley, CEO of Centricity Research, said. And when the information is both voluminous and irrelevant to a person’s job, staff are likely to tune it out.
GCP requirements, for instance, haven’t changed in decades. The content of the regulation remains the same, and has never included a mandated length of time for GCP certification to last, he said. But in order to check off all possible boxes, most sponsors mandate GCP certification—usually their own—for every individual trial.
This type of ‘spray and pray’ training—in which all staff get the same exhaustive training—doesn’t make sense and wastes clinical staff’s valuable time. Additionally, when research staff are inundated with masses of content irrelevant to their jobs, the information overload makes it more likely that they will forget content that is relevant.
But tailoring training to both the protocol and the people who need it not only will better assure a sponsor that each employee at a site is getting exactly the training they need, but it will save research staff the time burden of going through training they don’t need.
And the right training approach—one that helps identify areas of weakness or poor performance before a trial begins—will ensure that those that need extra help get it, while not forcing more proficient staff to sit through unnecessary training. This approach can also reduce protocol deviations, thus avoiding time- and money-sucking retraining after a study has begun.
Training should reflect the need to change or develop specific behaviors, Rouse explained. If a procedure or patient visit is to be done in a way that is different from the standard, staff will have to change familiar and ingrained behaviors. For example, when sites are trained in enrollment procedures for a given trial, they are expected to implement those procedures over time, sometimes with a considerable amount of lag time between receiving the training and enrolling patients. Training that lacks clear illustrations of important things like inclusion/exclusion criteria, visit timelines and schedules will be harder for staff to retain, Rouse said.
Sponsors need to consider whether the training they provide is focused enough on the specifics of the protocol. While some companies recognize that it’s not necessary to include standard-of-care, common procedures or well-known clinical practices, others take more of a cover-your-ass approach and include everything remotely relevant to the daily practices of a clinical trial.
A compromise approach for sponsors that want to be able to say they have covered every contingency could be to provide a written manual or slide deck for staff to use as a reference, but make the training more targeted, Rouse suggested.
Trainer, resources also important
Another consideration is who provides the training. This task is often given to CRAs, whose skills may not include effective teaching and commonly defaults to a mere re-reading of the protocol or rote presentation of PowerPoint slides that don’t address knowledge gaps at the research site.
“Someone reading the protocol is not useful,” Kingsley said. “We’ve already done that. Go into the science behind it and discuss what isn’t written in the protocol.”
Visualizations, flow charts and decision trees can help staff quickly understand the fine details of specific procedures than a half-day webinar or 200-page manual, Harper said, adding, “The goal of training should be to demystify the protocol and help site staff through the operational procedures.”
Kingsley added that sponsors should consider adult learning theory when developing training. For instance, training could have pieces aimed at people who learn best by reading, those who learn best visually and those who learn best by doing the activity. The 70-20-10 rule could also be useful, acknowledging that only 10% of adult learning comes from curriculum; 20% comes from mentorship and the remaining 70% from the capacity to connect with others on how best to accomplish tasks and goals.
He also advocated use of online communities where research site staff can pose questions to and have discussions with others working in the same areas or on the same protocol.
And it’s important that sponsors not assume what sites need in terms of training. Sites should be selected because of their general clinical trial skills, so training should focus tightly on the protocol, Rouse said. One way this could be achieved is by getting input from sites on what training they need to ensure thorough understanding of the protocol.
This approach to training does require an upfront investment. But when enrollment lags or deviations occur due to training failure, sponsors will have to take the time, effort and cost to retrain staff anyway. And retraining further adds to the time burden on research staff.
Standardization sought, industry solutions few
Standardization of boilerplate training that applies to most clinical trials—ideally provided by an independent third party rather than a sponsor—would go a long way toward reducing training-related burdens on research staff, Kingsley said.
Training redundancy can act as a huge time sink for research sites. Some industry efforts have been made to reduce redundancies. Transcelerate, for instance, has aimed to reduce inefficiencies through efforts like a shared investigator platform to streamline certain boilerplate activities like general GCP training. The idea is that if researchers at a site are certified through a Transcelerate partner GCP course, that certification would be accepted by other partners.
“A lot of times, anything in the training that is not protocol-specific is going to lead to redundancy,” Rouse said. “The simplest thing is to see if there is a standard version of the training you want to deliver—such as EUCTR, informed consent, or GCP—and tap into that to relieve redundancy burdens on sites. An hour of a site’s time is worth saving; it is better for them to spend that time on finding the right trial participant than doing more routine certification.”
Kingsley also pointed to retraining related to protocol amendments as an unnecessary burden. Many protocol amendments are narrow in scope and irrelevant to many staff. For instance, an amendment that affects how labs operate still leads to the entire study staff having to take time to undergo the retraining. It would be better to focus amendment-related training to only the staff that would be affected by the change, he said.
“But redundancy is not necessary,” Rouse said. “Anytime a sponsor can choose a central GCP or other program as a standard, that will reduce the burden on sites.”
The ACRP also provides a GCP training program, including a simulation approach launched last year, with an eye toward a standardized approach that reduces the number of times sites have to complete GCP certification.
And WCG offers a survey designed to help sponsors determine how much of a burden their study would place on a site based on protocol and operational complexity.
However, it’s unclear how much traction this type of project can gain, as many sponsors want to use their own courses.
But sponsors should begin to view research site staff as high-value customers as a first step to addressing these burdens, Ballenger suggested. That means examining all processes and requirements to find ways to reduce friction and support the site. For instance, in terms of training, a stack of PowerPoint slides is unlikely to be appealing to most sites; sponsors should look at ways to signal that they care about the site’s learning experience.
To learn more about a training approach that is tailored to the needs of users and sites, visit http://proficiency1.wpenginepowered.com/simulation-training
Dave Hadden is an entrepreneur and technology innovator, founding Pro-ficiency and pioneering the fields of A.I.-based medical decision-support, Training Analytics, and Virtual Patient Simulation (VPS). Dave has focused his passion for technological innovation and learning systems in the field of clinical trials, helping sponsors make their studies more accurate and efficient through finding the right technology mix such as virtualization, performance management and applied behavioral sciences to produce the most effective, lasting, and engaging results for clinical trials.
The 9 Things Your Parents Teach You About UK Pornstar uk Pornstar
Attorney For Accident Claim: What’s The Only Thing Nobody Has Discussed catastrophic accident attorney –
Kathlene –
12 Facts About Search Engine Optimization To Make You Seek Out Other People
Search Engine Optimization London
The Most Profound Problems In Repair A Window Double Glazed Window Repairs Near Me
10 Myths Your Boss Has About CSGO Most Profitable Cases CSGO Most
Profitable Cases Wildfire case
25 Shocking Facts About Double Glazing Near Me secondary Double Glazing near me
What’s The Reason? Part Time Work From Home Jobs Is
Everywhere This Year weekend work from home jobs
Ten Pinterest Accounts To Follow Top 10 Pornstars most popular pornstars
The Unspoken Secrets Of Cost Of Replacement Windows Uk timber
20 Trailblazers Lead The Way In Upvc Window Repairs window repairs Near me
The 10 Most Popular Pinterest Profiles To Keep Track Of Porsche Key Shell Replacement porsche keys
14 Common Misconceptions About Backlink Builder Software automatic backlink creator Software
How To Save Money On Search Engine Optimization Agency seoranker.ai Search engine optimization
Guide To Locksmith Auto Key: The Intermediate Guide For Locksmith
Auto Key locksmith Auto key
10 Things That Everyone Is Misinformed About
The Word “Ai Rewrite Text” Rewrite Content Ai
What Do You Know About Car Diagnostic Garage Near Me? diagnostic for car Near me
Why You Should Concentrate On Making Improvements Double Glazed Window Near Me Double Glazing Window
Do Not Believe In These “Trends” About Upvc Window Repairs window repairs near me; Lori,
11 Strategies To Completely Redesign Your Best Online Jobs Work From Home weekend Work from home jobs
25 Surprising Facts About Leeds Windows And Doors Near By
Why Work From Home Jobs Online Uk Is More Difficult Than You Imagine work from home jobs online – Hannelore –
10 Healthy Glass Repair Leeds Habits upvc window handle repairs leeds, dsred.com,
9 . What Your Parents Teach You About Replace Window Handles replace
window handles (http://www.themcwars.Org)
Leeds Double Glazing: What Nobody Is Talking About
glass replacement leeds – Shenna –
10 Things Everyone Has To Say About Peugeot 208 Key
Replacement Peugeot 208 Key Replacement replaced
30 Inspirational Quotes About Planet Spa Beauty Sleep planet
spa beauty sleep (http://littleyaksa.yodev.net/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=6130033)
10 Quick Tips About Car Locks Smith lost car key locksmith
What To Focus On When Making Improvements Content Marketing Agency
London Digital content marketing
Will Erb’s Palsy Claim Never Rule The World? Erb’s Palsy Law Firm
You’ll Never Be Able To Figure Out This Upvc Window Repair’s Secrets
window Repair
5 Killer Quora Answers To Double Glazing Repairs Leeds glazing repairs Leeds,
http://www.demilked.com,
7 Simple Tips To Totally Doing The Situs Alternatif Gotogel
Heylink.Me
8 Tips To Up Your Ghost Ii Immobiliser Game watch
20 Glass Repair Leeds Websites Taking The Internet By Storm repair double glazing (Earl)
A Proficient Rant Concerning Bmw Key Lost bmw key
5 Killer Quora Answers On SEO For Near Me Searches Seo For Near Me Searches
20 Insightful Quotes About CSGO Best Betting Sites case Revolver
3 Common Causes For Why Your Double Glazing Repair Cost
Isn’t Performing (And Solutions To Resolve It) upvc door repairs near
me (Mallory)
See What Situs Alternatif Gotogel Tricks The Celebs Are Using situs alternatif gotogel, Jenny,
10 Double Glazed Window Leeds That Are Unexpected Window Doctor Leeds
Why Nobody Cares About Online Shopping Uk For Clothes
Vimeo.com
A Handbook For Double Glazed Window Repair From Beginning
To End Window Repairs Near Me
Quiz: How Much Do You Know About Online Work? home based jobs near me
One Of The Most Innovative Things That Are Happening With 10kg Washing Machines
– All Offers New 10Kg Washing Machine
The 10 Most Scariest Things About Double Glazing Repairs Near Me double glazing near me
10 Things That Your Family Teach You About Door Fitter Leeds fitter
See What American Fridge Frezzers Tricks The Celebs Are Using american fridge frezzers (Doris)
Double Glazed Window Repairs: The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly Double Glazing Repair
Don’t Buy Into These “Trends” About Fridge Freezer Black buy fridge Freezers
10 Life Lessons That We Can Learn From Car Lawyers Near
Me attorney car accident near me (Theo)
15 Ideas For Gifts For The Best Robot Vacuum 2023 Lover In Your Life best robot vacuum for hardwood floors (Wayne)
What Will Emergency Car Locksmith Be Like In 100 Years?
locksmiths for Cars
“The Ultimate Cheat Sheet” For Double Glazing Showrooms Near Me double glazing window keys
New And Innovative Concepts That Are Happening With Uk Online Phone Shopping Sites 80 Gallon 2-Stage Compressor (Carson)
Ten Things You’ve Learned In Kindergarden To Help You Get Started With Sofas For Sale
comfiest Couches
10 Tips For Quickly Getting Used Sofas For Sale cheap sofa bargains
11 Ways To Completely Revamp Your Mobility Scooter Shops Near Me where can i buy a mobility scooter near me
Nine Things That Your Parent Taught You About Replace Upvc Window Handle replace upvc window
handle (Christine)
9 Lessons Your Parents Taught You About Locksmith Car Locksmith Car
12 Facts About Mesothelioma Lawsuit To Make You Think About The Other
People Binghamton Mesothelioma attorney
What Is It That Makes Window Repair Near So Famous?
upvc repairs
Nine Things That Your Parent Teach You About Recliner Couches For Sale recliner couches
for sale (Roxie)
Best Automatic Folding Mobility Scooter Uk Tools To Help You Manage Your Daily Life
Best Automatic Folding Mobility Scooter Uk Trick That Everybody
Should Learn Best Automatic Folding Mobility Scooter Uk
Is Best CSGO Gambling Sites Just As Important As Everyone Says?
Case opening (http://lineyka.org)
15 Weird Hobbies That’ll Make You Better At L Shaped Couches For Sale
Grey Leather Couch
17 Signs You’re Working With How Many Cases Are There In CSGO
cs2 Cases
Nine Things That Your Parent Taught You About Recliner Couches For Sale recliner
Watch Out: How Adults Bunk Bed Is Taking Over And How To Stop It Bunk Bed Sale
9 . What Your Parents Teach You About Car Ghost Immobiliser Car Ghost Immobiliser
15 Trends That Are Coming Up About Locksmith Near Me
For Car locksmith For car Near me
See What Situs Gotogel Terpercaya Tricks The Celebs Are Using Situs Gotogel terpercaya
9 Lessons Your Parents Teach You About Software For Seo Link Building
Software For Seo Link Building
What’s The Job Market For Upvc Window Handle Replacement Professionals Like?
upvc Window handle replacement
It’s True That The Most Common Best Robot Vacuum For Carpet Debate Actually Isn’t As Black
And White As You May Think best robot vacuum For thick Carpet
And pet hair, blum-mccurdy-3.mdwrite.net,
Slot Demo Pragmatic It’s Not As Hard As You Think
5 Lions Demo
The Most Hilarious Complaints We’ve Seen About
Cerebral Palsy Claim cherokee village cerebral palsy attorney
A How-To Guide For Ghost Immobiliser From Start To Finish ghost Immobiliser installation
How To Beat Your Boss On Link Login Gotogel link daftar Gotogel
The 9 Things Your Parents Teach You About Double Glazing Window Repairs Near Me window Repairs near me
How To Make An Amazing Instagram Video About Window Repairs upvc windows repair Near me
Guide To Glass Window Replacement: The Intermediate Guide The Steps To
Glass Window Replacement Glass window Replacement
Average Cost Of Car Diagnostic Uk 101: A Complete Guide For Beginners car
Why People Don’t Care About Fiat 500 Key Replacement
Fiat 500 Replacement Key Cost Uk
How To Make A Successful Repair Double Glazing Window Instructions For Homeschoolers From Home
double glazing repairs (https://te.legra.Ph/14-Companies-Doing-An-Excellent-Job-At-Ashford-Door-Panels-09-08)
10 Graphics Inspirational About Glazing Repair Near Me double glazing repair
Five Killer Quora Answers On Windows Replacement windows replacement
15 Unexpected Facts About Mini Cooper Key Fob That You Never Known Replacement Mini Keys
20 Trailblazers Are Leading The Way In Window.Replacement Near Me window replacement companies (Julio)
A Productive Rant About Best Coffee Machines latte Machines
How To Outsmart Your Boss On Bunk Beds For Kids Bunk Bed Online
Coffee Machines From Bean To Cup Tools To Make Your Daily Life Coffee
Machines From Bean To Cup Trick That Everyone Should Learn coffee machines from bean To cup
Leeds Window Repair: What’s The Only Thing Nobody Has Discussed Glazing leeds
10 Ford Replacement Key Cost Uk Tricks All Experts Recommend new ford Key fob
The 12 Most Obnoxious Types Of Users You Follow On Twitter Green Power 4-Wheel Electric Mobility Scooter for Sale